On, Amendment 3, who should decide the future of your community?

Before you decide how to vote on Amendment 3, ask yourself a broader question: How much control over your community do you want to give Tallahassee?

Florida families have been struggling with affordability for years. Homeowners insurance remains extraordinarily expensive, and Florida drivers continue to pay some of the highest auto insurance premiums in the country. Yet the “solution” being offered is a constitutional amendment that permanently restricts the primary source of revenue local governments use to provide the services residents see and use every day.

This is about much more than municipal budgets and claims that Tallahassee wants to give relief to homeowners. It is about home rule. Year after year, Tallahassee passes laws preempting local governments and replacing local decisionmaking with a one-size-fits-all approach. Amendment 3 takes that trend much further because it doesn’t simply tell local governments what they can do, it restricts the resources available to do it.

When local governments lose the ability to raise enough revenue locally to meet their communities’ needs, where will they turn? Tallahassee. And when the money flows from Tallahassee, so does the influence. That means decisions about your police, fire rescue, roads, drainage, parks, infrastructure and other local priorities increasingly become dependent upon decisions made hundreds of miles away rather than by the people you elect right here at home.

This isn’t some abstract warning from county and city officials anymore. Florida sheriffs, police organizations, firefighters and fire chiefs have publicly raised concerns about Amendment 3 and its potential effect on public safety and emergency services. And because this would be written into the Florida Constitution, changing course later would be exceedingly difficult. A future Legislature couldn’t simply amend the law after communities begin experiencing unintended consequences.

For those relishing the potential cost savings if Amendment 3 passes, think about your home and its current market value. Now put it on a truck and move it to another community where property values are substantially lower. Is it worth the same? Of course not. Your house didn’t change. The community around it did.

Your property value isn’t determined only by the house itself. It is also a reflection of the community around it — safe neighborhoods, good roads, effective drainage, quality parks and infrastructure, and strong public safety. Those things have value, and they cost money to provide. So before leaping at a lower tax bill, think about what you are willing to give up to get it. Because the costs don’t simply disappear. Property taxes aren’t just a cost of owning your home. They are part of the investment that makes your community a place people want to call home.

There is absolutely a legitimate debate to be had about property taxes, government spending and whether local governments are spending responsibly. Taxpayers should demand accountability from us. But accountability means more that just demanding that government spend less. It means deciding what level of services you expect from your community and whether you are willing to pay what it costs to provide them.

So when considering Amendment 3, don’t look only at the number it might take off your tax bill. Look at what those dollars currently buy. Ask yourself what you are willing to give up and who you want making the decisions about your community when the funding is gone.

Michael Napoleone is mayor of the Village of Wellington.

First appeared on the Sun-Sentinel