Vote no on Amendment 3

Letters to the Editor – October 25, 2026

In both of his campaigns for governor, Gov DeSantis used this slogan as his mantra; “You know better what you need in (name of community or county he was in) than they do in Tallahassee.” No matter what town he was campaigning in, that line was boldly proclaimed. Local rule was highlighted for many good reasons. However, once he was in office, things changed and time and again, the powers that be in Tallahassee overruled decisions made by local government leaders.

Local environmental efforts across the state were the first to be overruled and struck down. Then, one by one, local leaders were removed from office by the governor for a variety of reasons, some just and some very questionable. And there is no bigger example of government overreach than Alligator Alcatraz, a multimillion-dollar mistake paid for by Florida taxpayers (The check is in the mail from DC. Coming any day now) that scarred the Everglades in ways not yet determined.

While I understand that no one wants to pay more taxes, the often-unspoken secret about home ownership in SW Florida is that the seasonal owners are picking up a significant percentage of the costs of living here and only get to enjoy those benefits a few months out of the year. Consequently, year-round residents are getting tax benefits often never acknowledged. Most seasonal owners will not get a tax benefit from Amendment 3, but continue to pick up a disproportionate part of the cost of living here a few months out of the year. Just imagine what the taxes might be like if many of those seasonal owners choose to sell their homes here, glutting the current market with even more homes on sale and decreasing current home values.

Local rule works best when it is administered by those who know the community’s needs and values and is properly funded. Amendment 3 clearly is a “tax shift” not a “tax break.” The services that make our communities appealing and desirable are at risk when powers far beyond the local communities are making the decisions about funding them.

Vote No on Amendment 3.

David Minnick, Fort Myers

Loss of essential local services

Every few days, it seems another organization comes out in opposition to Amendment 3. While paying less in property taxes may sound appealing, this proposal is far more drastic than many voters realize. Amendment 3 is not simply a tax cut. It is a potential reduction in essential local services and a shift of costs that communities will ultimately have to absorb.Property taxes fund many of the services Floridians depend on every day, including law enforcement, fire rescue, parks, libraries, and animal services. If local governments lose significant revenue, elected officials will be forced to make difficult decisions about which programs to reduce, eliminate, or replace with new fees and taxes. We citizens will pay for it either through the loss of essential services or via other fees and taxes levied to try to maintain those services.When a house is on fire, we expect someone to respond. When a crime is being committed, we expect law enforcement to be there. The same is true when an animal is lost, injured, neglected, or in danger. Animal services agencies and animal control officers provide critical public safety, public health, and animal welfare services that benefit both people and pets. These resources are already stretched to the maximum. As an animal welfare advocate, I am extremely concerned about the loss of these services. Before supporting Amendment 3, voters should become educated on what might be lost if local government is forced to operate with substantially fewer resources.

Suzanne Thomas, Naples

Bradenton Herald